Roundup Products Liability Litigation (MDL) Reference : 3:16-md-02741-VC Complaint date : No description Status : Not judged Place of jurisdiction : United States, Northern District of California Plaintiffs types : Farmers, Landscapers Plaintiffs names : Hardeman (3:16-cv-00525), Stevick (3:16-cv-02341), Gebeyehou (3:16-cv-05813), Penrod (3:16-cv-5901), Bridgeman (3:16-cv-00812), Means (3:16-cv-05753), Giglio (3:15-cv-02279-BTM-WVG), Nash-Boulden (18-02028), Vacante (18-02079), Walker (18-02080), Subers (18-05274), Petty et al (18-00293), Ottinger (18-01370), Adelson (17-01095), Cash (18-01000)... Defendants : Monsanto, Ragan and Massey, Inc Lawyers for Health and Environmental Justice : Aimee Wagstaff, David J. Wool, Kathryn M. Forgie, Lori E. Andrus, Vance R. Andrus, Robin Greenwald, Michael Miller, Michael L. Baum, Edward A. Wallace, Corey G. Lorenz, Yvonne M. Flaherty, Caroline C. Schadle, Tesfaye Wolde Tsadik, Anthony P. Ellis, Jennifer A. Moore, Timothy Litzenburg Case nature : Civil court Specificities : Multi-district litigation Type(s), Product(s), Active substance(s) : Glyphosate, Roundup, Herbicide Requests : Compensatory damages, economic damages in the form of medical expenses, out of pocket expenses, lost earnings, Punitive and/or exemplary damages for the wanton, willful, fraudulent, and reckless acts of the defendants, Pre and Post-judgment interest, Plaintiff reasonable attorneys’ fees, the costs of these proceedings. Name of the Court : District court of Northern District of California, United States Jurisdiction level : Summary : Many legal complaints (1654 as of October 2018 - up to 125,000 in June 2020) against Monsanto from Roundup users diagnosed with non-Hodgkin's lymphomas have been regrouped at the Northern District of California District Court. 7/10/2018, Judge Vince Chhabria concluded a reasonable jury could find that glyphosate can cause non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma at exposure levels people realistically may have experienced. First case is Hardeman v. Monsanto (3:16-cv-00525). Hearings have begun on 2/25/2018. Then there will be the cases of Stevick v. Monsanto that is planned for Feb. 24, 2020 and Gebeyehou v. Monsanto (3:16-cv-0581). On Jan. 3, the judge decided to "bifurcate" the 3 bellwether cases, which means that only the evidence that Roundup contributed to the plaintiffs' cancer will be examined in a first phase, and only if the answer is yes will Monsanto's pressuring and lobbying tricks be examined. Following the 1st verdict (Hardeman v. Monsanto), the judge ordered the plaintiffs' and defendants' lawyers to meet quickly to consider out-of-court settlements. He appoints Kenneth Feinberg as mediator. He had managed the compensation fund after September 11 and the one due to the explosion of the BP Deepwater Horizon oil rig in the Gulf of Mexico. In 1984, he mediated the class-action lawsuit brought by 250,000 Vietnam War veterans against the manufacturers of Agent Orange. On 5/30/2019, Monsanto asks that Roundup cancer lawsuits be moved out of California. On 6/14/2019, Judge partly grants the request (for some cases). On June 24, Bayer settles U.S. Roundup, dicamba and PCB litigation for more than $10 billion. Plaintiffs Johnson, Hardeman and Pilliods, which cases have been appealed, are not part of the agreement. On 7/6/2020, a preliminary order from Judge Chhabria states that the Court is skeptical of the propriety and fairness of the proposed settlement, and is tentatively inclined to deny the motion. On 7/8/2020, Bayer withdraws proposal for class action settlement of future Roundup claims. On 8/26/2020, Judge Chhabria said he’s concerned Bayer has “manipulated” the settlement process since announcing its plan in June and will revisit in a month whether to keep the litigation on hold for settlement talks to continue or to let more trials proceed. On Sept. 14, 2020, a final settlement with three major law firms representing thousands of plaintiffs is reached. The firms each filed notification of the deals with the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California. Bayer says that it is making progress in the development of a “revised” plan to resolve potential future Roundup litigation. On Feb. 3, 2021, Bayer announces a new $2 billion plan to resolve future Roundup cancer litigation that would compensate “qualified claimants” over a four-year program. Plaintiffs’ class counsel are filing a motion for preliminary approval of the class agreement. The plan must be approved by Judge Vince Chhabria. On May 26, 2021, the motion is denied. If a settlement that reasonably protects the interests of Roundup users who have not been diagnosed with NHL can be reached, that agreement must be presented on a new motion for preliminary approval. Scientific references : IARC Working Group on the Evaluation of Carcinogenic Risks to Humans. Some Organophosphate Insecticides and Herbicides. Lyon (FR): International Agency for Research on Cancer; 2017. PMID: 31829533. Related links : Patients: Roundup gave us cancer as EPA official helped the company Roundup Lawsuit: Lymphoma Patients Take On Monsanto important news and information about access to proceedings and to case information Monsanto Judge Won't Block Cancer Victims' Key Witnesses List of plaintiffs in MDL 3:16-md-02741-VC Court Appoints Leadership In Roundup Cancer MDL McCall v. Monsanto Company Stevick et al v. Monsanto Company References of all actions Federal Monsanto Roundup Multidistrict Litigation (MDL) Schedule Monsanto case: Man may not live long enough to get to court after judge’s decision First Federal Monsanto Roundup Trial Begins Monday in San Francisco Lawyer Who Handled Sept. 11 Victims Fund To Mediate Talks Between Bayer, Plaintiffs Monsanto wants Roundup cancer lawsuits moved out of California Judge partly grants request to move some trials over Monsanto herbicide Bayer announces agreements to resolve major legacy Monsanto litigation Bayer settles U.S. Roundup, dicamba and PCB litigation for more than $10 billion Round-up : Bayer choisit de payer pour éviter le procès (FR) Roundup Maker to Pay $10 Billion to Settle Cancer Suits Bayer's weedkiller cancer legal settlement offers only fleeting relief to shareholders Pre-trial order 214: Denying motion to alter schedule on motion for preliminary approval Court frowns on Bayer’s proposed Roundup class-action settlement Notice of motion to withdraw class action settlement plan Some US Roundup plaintiffs balk at signing Bayer settlement deals; $160,000 average payout eyed Bayer’s $11 Billion Roundup Deal Faces New Concerns From Judge Bayer inks deals with three Roundup cancer law firms as settlement progresses Bayer's agreement with plaintiffs’ counsel on class plan, Feb. 3, 2021 Bayer makes new $2 billion plan to head off future Roundup cancer claims Order denying Bayer class plan Judge kills Bayer’s plan to limit future Roundup legal liability, issues harsh criticism